A tomahawk gets ordered as much for how it looks as how it eats, and that’s fine, it’s genuinely a good cut. It’s just worth knowing what you’re actually paying the premium for before you commit to one.
What a tomahawk actually is
It’s a bone-in ribeye, the same cut as scotch fillet, just left on the bone, with the rib bone trimmed clean and left long rather than cut back close to the meat. That long, cleaned bone is what gives it the axe-handle look the name comes from. Same muscle, same marbling, same eating experience as a boneless ribeye of the same grade. The bone is presentation, not a different cut of meat.
What the bone adds, and what it doesn’t
It doesn’t add flavour to the meat in any way you’d actually taste, that’s more folklore than fact, and worth saying plainly rather than repeating the marketing line. What it does do is insulate the meat closest to it slightly during cooking, which matters for how evenly it cooks through, and it adds genuine visual drama to a table, which is most of the actual reason people order it. It also adds weight you’re paying for that you can’t eat, worth knowing going in, since a tomahawk’s price reflects the whole piece, bone included.
None of that makes it a bad choice. It just means the honest reason to order one is the occasion and the presentation, not a belief that the bone is quietly making the steak taste better while it cooks.
Weight and serving size
A tomahawk typically runs somewhere around 800g to 1.2kg depending on how it’s cut, which sounds like a lot until you remember a decent chunk of that is bone rather than meat. It’s usually positioned as a cut for two people to share rather than a single serve, and that’s roughly right, it’s a big steak, but not quite as big as the raw weight suggests. Worth factoring that into how you plan sides, too; it eats more like a generous main for two than the centrepiece for four the size alone might suggest.
How to cook it: reverse sear, not straight onto the heat
Its thickness is exactly the situation reverse searing was made for, bring it up gently in a low oven first, then finish it hard and fast in a cast iron pan or over direct heat for the crust. Straight onto a hot grill the whole way through and you’ll burn the outside well before the inside’s anywhere close to done. We’ve covered the full method, temperatures and timing in How to Reverse Sear a Steak, the short version is the same principle, just applied to a bigger, thicker piece of meat.
Presenting and carving
Part of the point of a tomahawk is bringing it to the table whole before it’s cut, that’s where the bone earns its keep. Carve it by running a knife along the bone to free the meat in one or two large pieces, then slice against the grain into individual portions once it’s off the bone. Don’t skip resting it first, either; a piece this size holds a lot of heat and needs longer than a standard steak before it’s ready to carve.
If you’re feeding two and want to make a night of it, ask at the counter when we’ve got tomahawk in, it’s not always sitting in the display the way the smaller cuts are.
Macelleria Bondi · G09/180 Campbell Parade, Bondi Beach · Open 7 days · No bookings required
FAQs
What is a tomahawk steak? A bone-in ribeye with the rib bone left long and cleaned, rather than trimmed short, same cut and eating experience as a boneless ribeye, just presented differently.
Is a tomahawk steak worth the price? If you’re after the presentation and the experience of carving a big piece at the table, yes. If you’re purely after the best eating experience per dollar, a boneless ribeye of the same grade gets you there without paying for bone weight.
How long does a tomahawk take to cook? Roughly 45 minutes to an hour in total using a reverse sear, most of that is the slow oven stage, with only a couple of minutes at the end for the sear.
How many people does a tomahawk feed? Two comfortably, occasionally stretching to three with generous sides.
